White House Revokes Press Passes

Evan Choe • November 2nd, 2026


News outlets who had covered the White House for years could not enter on Sept. 19. President Donald Trump had revoked the press passes of Cable News Network (CNN), My Source for News, Opinion and the World (MS NOW) and Politico. He offered no legal rationale, claiming the outlets "purposely write negative news" (NPR). Within a week, the reporters were back inside under a court order, and on Oct. 13, federal judge Timothy Kelly ruled that they could stay the rest of the case. This asserts that the President cannot remove reporters simply because he does not agree with what they write, at least for now. What the courts have not yet taken any explicit stance on is how far judges can go in limiting the President’s executive power, which is the question making its way to an appeals court now.

Trump has slaughtered press rights in the past, including but not limited to when the White House banned coverage from CNN correspondent Jim Acosta after a heated exchange at a 2018 press conference. In 2025, he barred the Associated Press from major events after the outlet refused to use the new name "Gulf of America" (National Public Radio). Both of those fights were over one reporter. But now, Trump's latest ban took out three entire newsrooms at once, six weeks before the Nov. 3 midterm elections, a time where voters pay the most attention to what the President is doing.

The administration provided a few justifications. First, Trump pointed to the stories that had piled up over the past two years, adding that someone has a right to keep reporters away if they write 'false stories' all the time (The Hill). When asked to clarify what that entailed, the President did not give a specific example. Days later, lawyers of the White House added a new reason: “national security”, contending that the news sources published sensitive information, leaking “classified information”. As this ban was taken under review in court, the news outlets’ lawyers argued that the ban was meant to pressure them into friendlier cover and to deter other journalists (CBS News). In fighting against Trump’s decision, they brought up two main arguments: the First Amendment’s assertion that the government cannot punish the press for what it reports and due process’ guarantee that the government must give notice and a chance to respond before it takes something away. The Trump administration responded to this defense that White House access is a privilege, not a right (NPR).

On Sept. 24, U.S. District Judge Timothy Kelly reinstated the credentials solely on the argument that the press passes were likely taken without due process (NPR). However, there was no ruling made on legitimacy of the claims via the First Amendment, which rings alarm bells. A due process ruling only tells the White House how to act. Without one based on the First Amendment, the Trump administration could have formally published written standards, given the outlets a brief window to respond, and then revoked the passes regardless. Only an explicit First Amendment ruling corrects the root cause of the ban. Senior Timothy Liu found the first order did not really settle anything.

“The larger First Amendment question remains open,” Liu said. “The administration could likely impose restrictions for a second time”.

The reactions of other outlets emphasized the dangerous implications that these actions could have for all reporters and outlets. Following their removal from the White House, American Broadcasting Company (ABC), National Broadcasting Company (NBC), CBS and Fox News suspended their own White House coverage in solidarity. Junior Nathan Li claimed that was what made the response stand out.

“This was not about politics or ratings,” Li said. “It was about whether journalists can do their jobs at all.”

The administration responded by launching “Trump TV”, a 24-hour YouTube stream of the President’s events. The two responses offer opposite answers to who should show the public its president: independent reporters or the government itself. That choice affects our campus too. Most students encounter politics primarily through social media posts originating from the reporting of White House journalists. Their removal gives the government a greater degree of influence over how and when its internal affairs are presented to the public, which may obfuscate the truth. Some seniors will vote for the first time on Nov. 3, and a key factor in their decision making process will be premised off of footage whose origin they will probably never think to question. Freshman Rayaan Chachra said the President should not get to choose who covers him.

“The president should not have the power to dictate who gets to ask him questions," Chachra said. “It only leads to less accountability."

Kelly's temporary order on the case expired on Oct. 13, and that day, he replaced it with an injunction that rules that the outlets can stay until the case is over. The judge found that the White House illegitimately revoked the passes, not for national security reasons as they claimed, but labeling it as 'unlawful discrimination'. The administration appealed the injunction the next day, but it will stay in place until the D.C. Circuit considers it. So the press is back inside, and the courts are allowing them to stay for now. How long they remain there hinges on the question that no court has been willing to answer: whether or not the press has a constitutional right to be there, or merely a privilege that the president can revoke at a moment's notice.


Updates

Welcome to Peninsula High’s newspaper, The Pen! Make sure to check out our Instagram and issues with the links below!

Contact

Support

For advertising inquiries, please contact thepen.business@gmail.com

Please contact the Pen newspaper at: thepennews@gmail.com

Our adviser Jaymee DeMeyer may be reached during school hours at

310-377-4888 x652 -or-demeyerj@pvpusd.net