the pen - the official website of the pvphs newspaper
Pop and Politics
Yubin Chung • November 2nd, 2026
Dropped from Ed Sheeran’s tour after publicly making "Free Palestine" statements, Macklemore’s dismissal caused many other artists to withdraw from the tour. These withdrawals created divisions among celebrities and led Macklemore to organize his own independent tour. Along with these divisions, Macklemore’s conflict with Ed Sheeran sparked a debate on whether politics should be included in various forms of art, such as music. On one hand, it is argued that various forms of art should be linked with social struggle and moral awareness as a consistent way to express feelings and opinions. On the contrary, some consider the idea that popular music should provide an inclusive environment in which audiences can listen to music without having to worry about the artists’ opinions. Although many people believe artists should use their platforms to express their views, artists ought to keep their personal beliefs separate from their music.
Music should cater to everyone, no matter the genre. However, it should not contain the artists’ political beliefs. Commercial concert venues should bring people together rather than split them apart. When a fan buys a ticket to see their favorite artist in person, they make a commitment using their hard-earned money. It would be wrong to make political remarks from the stage because this would compel some people to take part in a political experience they had not paid for. Moreover, the opening acts of a concert carry out performances as part of a commercial arrangement intended to support the headliner; hence, making political statements on this shared platform ruins the atmosphere of the tour and places an unfair obligation on the main artist, forcing them to express views which they might not hold themselves. Macklemore acknowledged after his removal from the tour that his onstage political remarks put Sheeran in an unfair position that directly challenged the headliner's traditionally neutral stance (CBC News). From this point of view, the choice to exclude an artist is one of maintaining professional decorum and of setting and respecting boundaries. Junior Hudson Shim shared his beliefs on the separation of music and politics.
“Artists should try to keep themselves as separate from politics as possible,” Shim said. “While there is an underlying political message in everything, overtly stating your political beliefs can be incredibly controversial. It is not a good look for the artist.”
Opposedly, those who believe that politics should be part of music see this as an effort to turn art into a catalyst to spark change and awareness. Musical traditions throughout history—like those from the American Civil Rights Movement or the early days of hip-hop—have gained their cultural importance by challenging existing values, questioning state power, and speaking up for disadvantaged groups. If political commentary is removed from performances, artists lose their independence, and it is assumed that audiences are too sensitive to handle controversial topics. In Macklemore's case, since his artistic identity has always been based on advocacy, to punish him for doing so is to penalise him for engaging with his audience. Allowing artists to use their creative freedom is a belief junior Coral Vincent supports and tries to push.
“I think having politically [inspired] music is important,” Vincent said. “Throughout history, there have been rebellious songs or poems talking about hardships of the common man. I am against keeping music and politics separate.”
While free speech does provide a safeguard against government censorship, it does not mean that an artist has the right to promote and spread their own agenda on another artist’s tour. It is clear that giving solo performances, releasing one's own recordings and using personal social media accounts are mediums through which a person can express their political views without being directly criticized. There is, however, a practical difficulty when it comes to aligning an individual's personal beliefs with the expectations of the tour promoter in the case of a large concert that is jointly organised. Some people listen to the drama from afar and have a nuanced opinion on the matter, such as junior Samantha Hagopian.
“I adamantly believe that music should be a safe space for people,” Hagopian said. “But, [it] should also have some leniency, so artists can write and sing about current events as well as their personal opinions.”
The Loop tour drama has revealed two opinions on the matter, one side being supportive of Macklemore's removal after his “Free Palestine” remarks, while the other is against it. It is completely natural for audiences to desire places of communal enjoyment to escape global tensions, but art has always been shaped by people's opinions and by participation in civic struggles. Whether one sees concert stages as sanctuaries of entertainment or as megaphones for social justice, political views should be kept out of the music industry to accommodate all audiences.
Updates
Welcome to Peninsula High’s newspaper, The Pen! Make sure to check out our Instagram and issues with the links below!
Contact
Support
For advertising inquiries, please contact thepen.business@gmail.com
Please contact the Pen newspaper at: thepennews@gmail.com
Our adviser Jaymee DeMeyer may be reached during school hours at
310-377-4888 x652 -or-demeyerj@pvpusd.net